CMA — 7 Woodstock Dr | ProLegacy Realty
Comparative Market Analysis

7 Woodstock Dr

Toms River · New Jersey · 08757 · Holiday Heights (55+)
Bedrooms
2*
Bathrooms
2*
Living Area
1,328 sf
Garage
1-Car
Condition
Remodeled*
Estimated Market Value
$345,000–$365,000
Assumes full remodel · scope to be confirmed · November 2026
Recommended List Price
$339,000
Priced to create competition in a high-inventory market
Overview
Subject Property
55+ Community · Holiday Heights

7 Woodstock Dr

Toms River, New Jersey 08757 · Ocean County
7 Woodstock Dr
Model
Capri
Bedrooms / Baths
2 Bed / 2 Bath*
Living Area
1,328 sf
Year Built
1986
Garage
1-Car Attached
Interior Condition
Remodeled within ~7 years (scope TBC)*
Report Date
November 2026
Municipality
Toms River Township
Ownership
Fee Simple · Low HOA
Key Features
Capri Model
Remodeled
1-Car Garage
55+ Community
Single Level
Status
Remodel Scope To Be Confirmed
*Bedroom/bathroom count, square footage, and year built are from public records. The owner reports a remodel completed within approximately the last seven years; this analysis assumes a full remodel, but the scope, finish level, and date are not yet verified and will be confirmed at the listing walkthrough.
Market Data
Comparable Sales
46 Woodstock Dr
Comparable 01
Sold
46 Woodstock Dr
Toms River, NJ 08757 · Holiday Heights · 0.17 mi
$360,000
Sold Sep 14, 2026 · 1,364 sf · 84 DOM
2 Beds
2 Baths
Garage
Built 1986
Full Remodel
The benchmark. A fully remodeled home on the same street and the best recent sale in the area. At 36 sf larger than the subject, it sets the ceiling for a remodeled home here. It also took 84 days to sell, which shows how long even the best-condition home waits in the current market.
Gold standard · subject is 36 sf smaller → ~$350,000–$360,000 equivalent
Ceiling — full remodel
73 Chesterfield Ln
Comparable 02
Sold
73 Chesterfield Ln
Toms River, NJ 08757 · Holiday Heights · 0.07 mi
$335,000
Sold Aug 11, 2026 · 1,328 sf · 89 DOM
2 Beds
2 Baths
Built 1988
Medium-Low Condition
The same size as the subject (1,328 sf) in medium-low condition. It is the middle rung of the ladder: roughly $25,000 below the fully remodeled benchmark, and it took 89 days to sell.
Same size · medium-low condition → full remodel adds ~$25,000+
Middle rung — medium-low
49 Trent Dr
Comparable 03
Sold
49 Trent Dr
Toms River, NJ 08757 · Holiday Heights · 0.33 mi
$300,000
Sold Oct 6, 2026 · 1,328 sf
1,328 sf
Garage
Built 1990
Rough Condition
The same size as the subject, in rough condition, and the most recent closing in the set. It shows what a 1,328 sf home brings when it needs work, and why condition drives the spread in this community.
Same size · rough condition → floor for a 1,328 sf home
Floor — rough
55 Woodstock Dr
Comparable 04
Sold
55 Woodstock Dr
Toms River, NJ 08757 · Holiday Heights · 0.18 mi
$329,000
Sold Jul 13, 2026 · 1,232 sf · 36 DOM
2 Beds
2 Baths
Garage
Built 1986
Rough Condition
A smaller home (96 sf less than the subject) in rough condition that sold quickly, in 36 days. It shows that rough homes still move when priced for their condition, at roughly $300,000–$330,000 in this area.
96 sf smaller · rough condition → as-is tier
As-is tier
Comparable analysis considers size, condition, location, price, days on market, and current activity within the Holiday Heights / Holiday City-Berkeley area. Only closings from July through October 2026 are used. Condition ratings are the agent's on-the-ground assessments. Also considered but not pictured: 93 Guadalajara Dr (1,364 sf, sold $310,000 on Aug 20, 2026, rough) and 14 Woodstock Dr (1,124 sf, sold $284,900 on Aug 11, 2026, rough). Days on market are shown as reported by RPR where available. Adjustments are estimated and intended for broker opinion of value purposes only.
Subject
$345–365K
Est. Value · Full Remodel
List Price
$339K
Recommended
Comp 01
$360K
Full Remodel · Sold
Comp 02
$335K
Medium-Low · Sold
Comp 03
$300K
Rough · Sold
Pricing Analysis
Market Valuation
ProLegacy Realty · CMA

7 Woodstock Dr, Toms River NJ

Estimated Market Value
$345,000–$365,000
Holiday Heights · Capri · November 2026
46 Woodstock Dr — closed Sep 2026, full remodel (benchmark), 1,364 sf, 84 DOM $360,000
73 Chesterfield Ln — closed Aug 2026, medium-low, 1,328 sf, 89 DOM $335,000
55 Woodstock Dr — closed Jul 2026, rough, 1,232 sf, 36 DOM $329,000
93 Guadalajara Dr — closed Aug 2026, rough, 1,364 sf $310,000
49 Trent Dr — closed Oct 2026, rough, 1,328 sf $300,000
14 Woodstock Dr — closed Aug 2026, rough, 1,124 sf $284,900
Condition ladder: full remodel (subject, assumed) $345,000–$365,000
Condition ladder: medium-low $330,000–$340,000
Condition ladder: rough / as-is $285,000–$330,000
Recommended List Price $339,000
Methodology: Only closings from July through October 2026 are used. The ladder rests on real transactions: a fully remodeled 1,364 sf home at $360,000, a medium-low home of the same size as the subject at $335,000, and four rough homes between $285,000 and $330,000. The subject is a Capri of 1,328 sf, 36 sf smaller than the benchmark, so the estimate is set at $345,000 to $365,000 with the benchmark in the upper half. This assumes a full remodel; if the finishes fall short of the benchmark, the range moves down. Pricing Strategy: The area has high inventory and the benchmark remodel needed 84 days to sell. A list price of $339,000, just below the bottom of the value range, is intended to draw early showings and competing offers so the home can close inside the $345,000 to $365,000 range, not sit and chase the market down with price cuts.
Market Timing
Current Area Days on Market

Closed Comps (RPR)

Where RPR shows days on market for the closed comps: 55 Woodstock 36 days, 46 Woodstock 84 days, 73 Chesterfield 89 days. That averages about 70 days. The better-condition homes took the longest.

Holiday Heights (Redfin)

Redfin's Holiday Heights figure is about 70 days on market (reported around August 2026), in line with the closed comps above.

Holiday City–Berkeley (Redfin)

In November 2025, homes took an average of 35 days to sell versus 17 days a year earlier. Redfin's May 2026 snapshot showed a median of 33 days, with 139 active listings and 3.8 months of supply.

What It Means for This Listing

The area typically runs about 35 to 70 days, and inventory is elevated. Well-priced homes move faster; the longest waits in the comps came from higher-condition homes priced near the top of the market. Figures are as reported by each source for the dates noted, not a single current count.

Context & Strategy
Market Notes

Condition Reference (Agent Notes)

46 Woodstock: the gold standard, fully remodeled, $360K, 84 DOM. 73 Chesterfield: medium-low quality, $335K. 49 Trent, 55 Woodstock, 93 Guadalajara, 14 Woodstock: rough condition, $285K to $330K. The subject is assumed to be a full remodel based on the owner's report; the scope is to be confirmed at the walkthrough.

Holiday Heights Overview

Holiday Heights is part of the Holiday City at Berkeley 55+ community in Toms River. Homes are deeded (fee simple) with a very low monthly HOA, and the Capri is one of the community's popular single-level models. Buyers are typically retirees comparing many similar homes, so condition and price carry most of the weight.

Pricing Strategy & Buyer Psychology

With high inventory, buyers have choices and compare closely. The only recent full remodel sold at $360,000 after 84 days. Listing at $339,000 puts the subject below that benchmark, in front of the buyers who would otherwise see a rough home at a similar price.

What Could Change the Estimate

The remodel's scope, finish level, and age are the largest swing factors. A fully finished recent remodel supports the top of the range; a lighter or older update would move the estimate toward the middle rung of the ladder. The final numbers will be confirmed at the listing walkthrough.

Chris Farruggio

Chris Farruggio

Realtor Associate · ProLegacy Realty, LLC
📞 732-615-8806✉ Chris@prolegacyrealty.com

Buying or selling a home is one of the biggest decisions you'll make — and you deserve more than just a transaction. My goal is to showcase your property in the best possible light or help you find the perfect match that truly feels like home. Every client I work with receives dedicated service, clear communication, and a commitment to creating an exceptional experience from start to finish.

With over 20 years of experience in real estate investment, remodeling, and property management, I bring a unique perspective to the process. My background in construction management and house flipping allows me to help you see potential, avoid costly mistakes, and maximize your results — whether you're preparing to sell or searching for the right home.

Clients benefit from my strong negotiation skills, market knowledge, and hands-on approach. Whether you're a first-time buyer, seasoned investor, or homeowner ready to move on, I'm here to guide you with confidence and ensure every detail is handled with care.

PRO LEGACY REALTY LLC
This Comparative Market Analysis assumes a full interior remodel as reported by the owner; the scope, finish level, and date of the remodel, along with bedroom/bathroom count, are to be confirmed at the listing walkthrough and may materially affect the final estimated value and recommended list price. This report is prepared for informational purposes only and does not constitute a licensed appraisal. Values are based on available property data, comparable market activity, and current market conditions as of November 2026. All adjustments are estimated. Market conditions are subject to change. Days on market figures are as reported by the cited sources for the dates noted. This report does not guarantee any specific sale price.